After Midnight

• 
  Taylor Tomlinson
  Self
• 
  Thomas Lennon
  Self - Guest Star
• 
  Guy Branum
  Self - Host
• 
  James Davis
  Self
• 
  Paul F. Tompkins
  Short Carnie
• 
  Pete Holmes
  Self
• 
  Maria Bamford
  Shriek
• 
  Sandy Honig
  Self
• 
  Vinny Thomas
  Self
• 
  Marcella Arguello
  Self
• 
  Gillian Jacobs
  Self
• 
  Milana Vayntrub
  Self
• 
  Adam Pally
  Self
• 
  Kate Micucci
  Velma / Helga
• 
  Sherry Cola
  Self - Co-Host
• 
  Flula Borg
  Self
• 
  Arden Myrin
  Shelby
• 
  Betsy Sodaro
  Sonja
• 
  Lisa Gilroy
  Self
• 
  Colton Dunn
  Self - Contestant
• 
  Sasheer Zamata
  Self - Co-Host
• 
  Reggie Watts
  Self
• 
  Kimia Behpoornia
  Self
• 
  Aparna Nancherla
  Self
• 
  Kel Mitchell
  Self - Guest Celebrity
• 
  Andy Richter
  Self
• 
  Ashley Nicole Black
  Self
• 
  Melissa Villasenor
  Self
• 
  Rory Scovel
  Self
• 
  Jason Sklar
  Self
• 
  Kelsey Cook
  Self
• 
  Atsuko Okatsuka
  Self
• 
  Dulcé Sloan
  Self - Audience Member
• 
  Randy Sklar
  Self - Host
• 
  Doug Benson
  Self
• 
  Moshe Kasher
  Self
• 
  Kurt Braunohler
  Self
• 
  Carl Tart
  Self
• 
  Sarah Tiana
  Self
• 
  Blair Socci
  Self

• Sharon Everitt

• Michelle Davis
  ...
  (writer)
• Jo Firestone
  ...
  (head writer)
• Skyler Higley
  ...
  (staff writer)
• Ismael Loutfi
  ...
  (staff writer)
• Megan Neuringer
  ...
  (writer)
• Sam Taggart
  ...
  (staff writer)
• Dave Thomason
  ...
  (staff writer)
• Caroline Ulwick
  ...
  (staff writer)