HRAJí
- Kris Mohandie
Self - Mike McFarland
Timothy Krajcir - Allison Victoria-Wolfe
Krajcir's Wife - Todd Jenkins
Bruce Chesser - April Hartman
Scissors Victim - Martha Harms
Brenda Parsh - Leticia Magaña
Mary Parsh - Susana Gibb
Gwen Thoma - Dean Gosdin
Detective Jimmy Smith - Joshua Gage
Timothy Krajcir (5) - Rachel Dee
Donna Lauria - Sean McGraw
Floyd Parsh - Madison Laird
Stabbing Victim #1 - Maeghan Albach
Karen Chesser-Parsh - Sam Swanson
Robert Violante - Tom Costello Jr.
Interrogation Detective - Vandi Clark
Margie Call - Carl Denaro
Self - Shooting Survivor (archive footage) - Steven Jeffers
Lieutenant BJ Lincecum - Justin Labosco
Rick McGougan - Brad Stephens
Creepy Doctor - Elena Weinberg
Jody Valenti - Paul Echols
Self - Carbondale P.D. - Aaron M. Sanchez
Lauria Brother #1 - Nathan Gage
Timothy Krajcir (8) - Katie Dallas
Garden Shears Victim - Michael DeStefano
Timothy Krajcir (Teenage) - Hevin Hampton
Detective John Brown - Noelle Fabian
Pearl Berkowitz