Recently released from her vows as a nun, Christine Bennett is discovering "life on the outside." After a visit to her mentally-handicapped cousin Gene, Christine becomes embroiled in the investigation of the murder mystery surrounding James and Edward Talley, twin savant brothers accused of killing their mother on Good Friday, 1974.
- Megan WardChristine Bennett
- Morgan WeisserDet. Jack Brooks
- Rutanya AldaVirginia McAlpin
- David ProvalJames Talley / Edward Talley - Age 55
- Rafael FeldmanJames Talley
- Daryl SabaraJames Talley
- Yan FeldmanEdward Talley
- Evan SabaraEdward Tally
- Laura KirkAlberta Talley
- Rodger BumpassPatrick Talley, Jr.
- Lawrence PressmanDr. G.K. Sanderson
- Patty DukeMother Joseph